I actually give it a 3.5. I found this book to be enjoyable but very slow at parts. I felt it was missing the intrigue that the first one had. It didn't really shine any new light on the Luce/Daniel relationship - just asked more questions. I did enjoy the introductions of new characters. I really liked Miles and found Shelby very endearing. Luce I found to be rather stupid and whiny in this one, especially at the end - even though the Thanksgiving scene was the best. Am very interested in seeing how the next book goes and praying that there's finally some answers.